On The Basis Of Sex

Film Comprehension Unit · English Language

On the Basis of Sex

Mimi Leder · 2018 · Biographical legal drama · Based on a true story
American English 120 minutes Ruth Bader Ginsburg · Moritz v. Commissioner 1972 5 sections

1 · Overview

Film overview

On the Basis of Sex follows Ruth Bader Ginsburg from her first year at Harvard Law School in 1956 to her first major courtroom victory in 1972. The film traces her struggle to be taken seriously as a lawyer at a time when most firms refused to hire women, her years as a law professor teaching sex discrimination law without yet being able to practise it, and the case that changed her career: Moritz v. Commissioner. Charles Moritz, an unmarried man, had been denied a tax deduction for hiring a caretaker for his elderly mother — a deduction that a single woman in the same situation would have received automatically. Ruth and her husband Marty Ginsburg, a tax attorney, took the case together and argued it before the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. They won. The case became the foundation of Ginsburg's strategy for dismantling sex discrimination in American law.

The screenplay was written by Daniel Stiepleman — Ginsburg's own nephew. Ginsburg read the first three drafts. She had two conditions for the film: get the law right, and get Marty right. Ginsburg herself described the film as "part fact, part imaginative — but what's wonderful about it is that the imaginative parts fit in with the story so well."

Director
Mimi Leder
Screenplay
Daniel Stiepleman (Ginsburg's nephew)
Year
2018
Stars
Felicity Jones, Armie Hammer
Accent
American English (New York / academic)
Key case
Moritz v. Commissioner (1972)

Historical context

When Ruth Bader Ginsburg started at Harvard Law School in 1956, she was one of only nine women in a class of over 500. Dean Erwin Griswold famously asked each of the nine women at a dinner to justify taking a place from a qualified man. Despite graduating top of her class at Columbia (after transferring), she was turned down by every law firm she applied to. The reason, as she later put it: "ethnicity, sex, and motherhood trumped other attributes."

Ginsburg's legal strategy was deliberate and methodical. She understood that for sex discrimination to be struck down constitutionally, a series of precedents had to be built — just as Thurgood Marshall had built the legal framework that enabled Brown v. Board of Education in 1954. The Moritz case was chosen partly because the plaintiff was a man — making it harder for an all-male judiciary to dismiss the case as female self-interest. Ginsburg later went on to argue six landmark gender discrimination cases before the Supreme Court, winning five.

Characters

RG
Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Lawyer, law professor, future Supreme Court Justice · Played by Felicity Jones
Precise, determined, and initially overlooked. The film presents her as someone who chose strategy over emotion — she wanted to persuade judges, not confront them. Felicity Jones plays her as contained and watchful, with the intensity just below the surface. The real Ginsburg approved the portrayal, saying Stiepleman "made her seem a little less superhuman than she really was."
MG
Martin (Marty) Ginsburg
Tax attorney, Ruth's husband · Played by Armie Hammer
One of the film's most important choices: Marty is presented as a genuinely equal and supportive partner — cooking dinner, managing the household, and believing absolutely in Ruth's ability. This was historically accurate. In an era when such domestic arrangements were rare, their marriage was a quiet argument for what equality could look like.
MW
Mel Wulf
Legal director, ACLU · Played by Justin Theroux
A childhood friend of Ruth's who brings the ACLU's support to the Moritz case — and then tries to replace her as the lead courtroom attorney. His scepticism about Ruth's courtroom ability creates the film's central professional tension. The film presents his doubts as simultaneously understandable and unjust.
EG
Dean Erwin Griswold
Dean of Harvard Law School · Played by Sam Waterston
The film's most complex antagonist. Griswold is not cruel — he is the representative of an institution that genuinely cannot imagine women as full participants. His dinner question to the nine women is real and infamous. He later appears as the government's attorney opposing Ginsburg in the Moritz appeal, making his trajectory deeply ironic.
DK
Dorothy Kenyon
Civil rights advocate · Played by Kathy Bates
A pioneering female civil rights lawyer who has fought many of these battles before, often unsuccessfully. She is initially sceptical of the Moritz strategy — she has seen promising cases fail. Her eventual support matters because it comes from experience, not optimism.

Key themes

Sex discrimination in law
The film shows how discrimination against women was built into hundreds of federal statutes — not through hostility, but through assumption.
Strategic vs. emotional argument
Ginsburg's decision to lead with a male plaintiff and to educate rather than confront was a deliberate strategic choice. The film explores what this costs emotionally.
Marriage as partnership
The Ginsburgs' relationship challenges conventional gender roles at every level — professionally, domestically, and emotionally.
Institutional resistance
The film shows how institutions resist change — not through overt malice but through the accumulated weight of "the way things are done."
The law as a tool
Ginsburg believed the law could be an instrument of justice — but only if used precisely, patiently, and strategically.
Generations of change
The film spans 1956–1972 and closes with Ginsburg reaching the Supreme Court in 1993. How does social change actually happen — slowly, or in moments?

2 · Vocabulary

Legal vocabulary

TermMeaning / How it's used in the film
discrimination (n.)Unjust treatment of a person based on a characteristic such as sex, race, or religion. The film focuses specifically on sex discrimination — laws that treat men and women differently based on assumed social roles.
unconstitutional (adj.)In conflict with the principles set out in a country's constitution. The Ginsburgs argue that Section 214 of the tax code is unconstitutional because it treats people differently based on sex, violating the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.
precedent (n.)A previous court decision that guides or binds future decisions on the same legal question. Ginsburg's strategy was to build a series of precedents — small victories that together would make larger ones possible.
plaintiff (n.)The person who brings a case to court. Charles Moritz is the plaintiff in Moritz v. Commissioner — a choice Ginsburg made deliberately because a male plaintiff was harder for a male judiciary to dismiss.
oral argument (n.)A spoken presentation of a legal case before a court of appeal. The climax of the film is Ruth's oral argument before the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. It is her first time arguing in an appellate court.
equal protection (n.)A constitutional principle requiring that no person be denied the same protection of the law as others in similar circumstances. The 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause is the constitutional hook for Ginsburg's argument.
brief (n.)A written document submitted to a court before oral argument, laying out a party's legal arguments and evidence. Ruth writes the legal brief for Moritz — a document so thorough that when the government analyses it, they find it challenges hundreds of existing statutes.
statute (n.)A formal written law passed by a legislature. The government's computer analysis reveals that striking down Section 214 would challenge over 170 federal statutes — which is exactly Ginsburg's wider aim.
appellate court (n.)A court that reviews decisions made by lower courts. The Moritz case goes to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals — the level below the Supreme Court.
to litigate (v.)To take legal action; to argue a case in court. The ACLU agrees to finance the litigation of the Moritz case — covering the legal costs of taking it through the court system.
deduction (n.)An amount subtracted from taxable income, reducing the tax owed. Moritz was denied a tax deduction for hiring a caretaker for his elderly mother — a deduction a woman in the same situation would have received.
hagiographic (adj.)Describing someone in an excessively admiring way, like a saint's biography. Several critics called the film "hagiographic" — presenting Ginsburg so positively that it loses complexity. This is worth debating.

Key lines from the film

"A court ought not be affected by the weather of the day, but will be by the climate of the era."
Professor Freund, early in the film. This line establishes the film's central argument about legal strategy: courts respond to social change already underway, not to arguments ahead of their time. Ginsburg internalises this — she argues that the law should catch up with society, not lead it. The meteorological metaphor (weather/climate) distinguishes short-term resistance from long-term change.
"The Constitution does not contain the word 'woman.' Neither does it contain the word 'freedom.'"
Ruth's rebuttal to Judge Doyle, who objects that the Constitution never mentions women. This is one of the film's most celebrated lines — and historically attested. It uses the opponent's own logic against them: if the absence of a word meant the absence of a right, freedom itself would be unprotected. The parallel structure and the reversal make it devastating.
"I don't want to change society. I want the law to catch up with changes that have already taken place in society."
Ruth's counter-argument when the government accuses her of seeking radical social change. This is Ginsburg's strategic core: she presents herself as a conservative force, asking institutions to recognise what society already knows. The distinction between "changing" and "catching up" is rhetorically precise — and strategically brilliant.
"You will never win if you lead with emotion. You have to educate. Patient. Methodical."
Ruth's own description of her courtroom philosophy — echoed in different forms throughout the film. The three-word sequence "Patient. Methodical." is fragmented for emphasis — each word a separate instruction. The film frames this philosophy as both Ginsburg's strength and, at moments, an emotional cost: what does it mean to never lead with emotion when the injustice you are fighting is deeply personal?

Language register in the film

Speaker/contextRegisterWhat to notice
Ruth (professional)Precise, formal, controlledRuth's professional register is a deliberate performance — she knows that any emotional outburst will be used against her. Her sentences are complete, her vocabulary exactly chosen. Compare with how she speaks at home.
Ruth (domestic)Warmer, more direct, occasionally wryAt home with Marty, Ruth's language is more relaxed. The film uses this contrast to show her full range — and to show what she suppresses in professional settings.
Dean GriswoldAcademic, paternalistic, certainGriswold speaks with the confidence of an institution that has never had to justify itself. His register is inclusive-sounding ("all of us") while excluding ("a spot from a qualified man"). Listen for how his certainty is encoded in his grammar.
Marty GinsburgCharming, self-deprecating, warmMarty uses social warmth as a tool — he can navigate rooms Ruth finds hostile. He uses humour, self-deprecation, and apparent informality to defuse tension. His register is less guarded than Ruth's because society is less guarded towards him.
Government attorney BozarthProcedural, rhetorical, politicalBozarth frames the Ginsburgs' argument as a threat to "the American way of life" — escalating the register from legal to political. This is a rhetorical tactic: when you cannot win on the legal argument, broaden the frame. Listen for how Ruth refuses this escalation.

Vocabulary task

Without using a dictionary, guess the meaning of these words from their context in the film.

WordMy guess (from context)Confirmed meaning
precedent
unconstitutional
plaintiff
to litigate
hagiographic

3 · Questions

Literal comprehension

Answer using facts directly stated in the film.

1
What question does Dean Griswold ask the nine female law students at his dinner, and what does Ruth's answer reveal?
2
Why was Charles Moritz denied a tax deduction — and why does Ruth see this case as a strategic opportunity?
3
What does the government's computer analysis reveal when it searches for all laws relating to gender — and how does Bozarth use this in court?
4
What is the outcome of the Moritz v. Commissioner appeal, and what happens to Ruth's career afterwards?
Interpretive comprehension

Think about why characters act as they do.

5
Ruth chooses a male plaintiff deliberately. Why is this a strategic choice — and what does it reveal about her understanding of how change happens within the legal system?
6
Marty cooks, supports, and defers to Ruth's professional judgement throughout the film. How does the film use his character to make an argument about what equality looks like — and what it costs?
7
The moot court practice session goes badly for Ruth. What goes wrong — and why is this moment important for her arc?
Critical comprehension

Evaluate and argue. Support your view with evidence.

8
Ruth's strategy is to educate the judges, not confront them — to show that the law is out of step with society, not to argue that society should change. Is this the right approach? What does it gain — and what might it sacrifice?
9
The film has been called "hagiographic" — presenting Ginsburg as a near-perfect heroine with too few flaws. Do you think this is a fair criticism? Does a biographical film have a responsibility to complicate its subject?
10
The film ends with the real Ruth Bader Ginsburg walking up the Supreme Court steps. Why does the filmmaker choose to end this way — and what argument does this ending make about the relationship between individual effort and institutional change?
Creative response

Choose one. Write 150–250 words.

Option A
Write the diary entry Ruth might have written the night before the oral argument in the Moritz case — her first time arguing in an appellate court. What is she feeling? What is she telling herself? Write in her precise, controlled voice.
Option B
Write Dean Griswold's private response — in a letter or journal entry — after hearing the result of the Moritz appeal. He opposed Ruth at every stage. Now she has won. Is he able to acknowledge what she achieved — or does his language reveal that he cannot?

4 · Language

On the Basis of Sex is a film built on the power of precise language — in courtrooms, in lecture halls, and at kitchen tables. Ginsburg's legal strategy was a language strategy: choose the right words, the right frame, the right case, and the law could be moved. The film is also a study in how institutional language excludes, and how a precise counterargument can dismantle that exclusion.

Scene-by-scene language analysis

Scene 1 · 1956 Harvard Dean Griswold's dinner — the language of institutional exclusion
Dean Griswold
"Each of you is here tonight representing every woman who has ever applied to Harvard Law. I want each of you to tell me — why are you here at Harvard, taking the place of a man?"
Ruth
"My husband, Marty, is a second-year student. I thought it was important for a woman to understand her husband's work."
The question as trap
Griswold's question contains its own answer: "taking the place of a man" presupposes that a woman's presence is a displacement. Ruth cannot answer without accepting the premise — unless, as she does, she answers the surface question while ignoring the implied one. Her answer about her husband is a strategic performance: she gives him an answer that fits his frame while betraying nothing of her real ambitions.
Presupposition
Griswold's question contains a presupposition — an assumption embedded so deeply in the question that it seems unchallengeable. "Why are you taking a man's place?" presupposes law school is for men. Identifying and challenging presuppositions is one of the most important critical language skills — and one Ruth uses expertly in court.
Ruth's real answer
The real Ruth Bader Ginsburg gave this answer at Griswold's dinner and later recalled: "Did I believe that? Of course not!" The gap between her public answer and her private belief is the film's central tension — and its central subject. How much of who we present is strategy, and how much is truth?
Scene 2 · 1972 Court of Appeals Ruth's oral argument — language under pressure
Judge Doyle
"Counsel, the word 'woman' does not appear in the Constitution."
Ruth
"Nor does the word 'freedom,' Your Honour."
The reversal
Judge Doyle uses a textual argument — if the word doesn't appear, the concept doesn't apply. Ruth's reversal uses the same logic to expose its own absurdity: freedom is the Constitution's most fundamental concept, and it isn't there either. The structure is called reductio ad absurdum — showing that a logic leads to an obviously unacceptable conclusion.
Brevity as power
Ruth's response is seven words. She could have argued at length — but length would have weakened the point. The short, parallel structure ("Nor does... 'freedom'") makes the comparison irresistible. In legal argument, as in life, the briefest response is often the most devastating.
Tone
"Your Honour" is technically a term of address — but here it also performs deference while delivering the counter-argument. Ruth does not confront; she respects the form of the institution even as she challenges its content. This is her philosophical approach made grammatical.
Scene 3 · 1972 Court of Appeals The "radical change" argument — reframing the opponent's language
Bozarth (government attorney)
"The Ginsburgs and the ACLU want radical social change — they want to tear apart the fabric of the American family."
Ruth
"I do not ask this court to change society. I ask the law to catch up with changes that have already taken place in society."
Bozarth's escalation
Bozarth uses the language of threat — "radical," "tear apart," "the American family." These are political terms, not legal ones. He is trying to move the argument from law to culture, where the ground is less stable. This is a classic rhetorical technique: when the facts are against you, change the frame.
Ruth's reframe
Ruth refuses the frame entirely. She doesn't argue about whether radical change is good or bad — she redefines what she is asking for. "I do not ask this court to change society" — negation first — "I ask the law to catch up" — positive restatement. The word "catch up" implies the law is behind, not that society is ahead. This places her in the conservative position.
The power of reframing
Reframing — taking your opponent's language and replacing it with a different frame of meaning — is one of the most powerful tools in political and legal argument. Study how Ruth does it here. Can you identify other moments in the film where she or another character reframes an argument?

Grammar in context

StructureHow it appearsWhy it matters
Presupposition in questions
"Why are you taking the place of a man?"
Griswold's dinner question contains a presupposition — that law school is for men, and women's presence is a displacement. The question cannot be answered without accepting this premise unless the respondent challenges the frame.Recognising presuppositions — assumptions embedded in questions — is a key critical thinking skill in debate, law, and everyday conversation.
Reductio ad absurdum
"Nor does the word 'freedom.'"
Ruth uses her opponent's own logic to expose its absurdity: if the absence of a word means the absence of a right, then freedom itself would be unprotected by the Constitution.Reductio ad absurdum — showing that a position leads to an obviously unacceptable conclusion — is a classic and powerful form of logical argument.
Negation before affirmation
"I do not ask this court to change society. I ask the law to catch up."
Ruth consistently denies the opponent's framing before offering her own. The negative construction first ("I do not...") clears the space; the positive statement ("I ask...") fills it with her own meaning.This structure — negate, then affirm — is a fundamental rhetorical pattern. It is harder to dismiss than a simple positive claim because it explicitly addresses the counter-argument.
The passive voice as evasion
"Women have traditionally been excluded from..."
Characters who defend the status quo use passive constructions — things happened, exclusions were made, but nobody in particular is responsible. Ginsburg consistently uses active constructions when naming injustice: someone did this, and it was wrong.Passive voice removes human agency. When institutions describe injustice in the passive voice, they conceal who is responsible. Learning to identify this is a crucial critical reading skill.
Parallelism in argument
"Patient. Methodical. Strategic."
Ruth and others use parallel structures — lists of single words, matched clauses — to give arguments rhetorical force. The parallel structure implies that items are equivalent in importance and weight.Parallel structure is a fundamental rhetorical device. In spoken argument, it creates rhythm and memorability; in written argument, it signals balance and precision.

Language features

①
The weather and climate metaphor
Professor Freund's line — "A court ought not be affected by the weather of the day, but will be by the climate of the era" — introduces the film's central metaphor for legal change. Weather is short-term, unpredictable, local. Climate is long-term, structural, inexorable. Ginsburg's strategy is to work with the climate, not against it: to show courts that society has already moved, and the law must follow. Track how this metaphor plays out across the film.
②
Legal language and access to justice
The film is full of technical legal vocabulary — statutes, appellate courts, equal protection, briefs. This language is not incidental: it is part of the film's argument that access to legal language is itself a form of power. Ginsburg's ability to move fluently through this vocabulary — while many of the men she works with assume she cannot — is one of the film's recurring pleasures. Pay attention to moments where legal language is used to exclude or intimidate, and moments where Ginsburg turns it back.
③
The language of assumption
Many of the discriminatory laws in the film were not written out of hostility — they were written out of assumption. The tax code assumed that the person who would hire a caregiver for an elderly parent was a woman, so the deduction went only to women. Nobody thought to ask whether a man might do the same thing. This is one of Ginsburg's central arguments: that the law encodes the assumptions of those who wrote it, and those who wrote it assumed women stayed home. Language encodes worldview. The film shows what happens when that worldview is challenged.
④
The film's own language: hagiography or biography?
Critics used the word "hagiographic" — writing about a saint — to describe how the film treats Ginsburg. This is worth examining as a language question: what words would a hagiographic film use that a more critical one would not? What would Ruth say in her own defence that the film withholds? The film's language choices — who is shown to be right, whose doubts are presented sympathetically, when humour softens a difficult moment — all encode its attitudes toward its subject. Reading a film's language means asking: who is this film for, and what does it want us to feel?

Language tasks

Task A — Identify the presupposition
Find three moments in the film where a character's question or statement contains an embedded presupposition — an assumption that goes unchallenged by the grammar of the sentence. For each: write the original line, identify the presupposition, and write a version of the sentence that makes the assumption explicit rather than hidden.
Task B — Reframe the argument
The government attorney Bozarth accuses the Ginsburgs of wanting "radical social change." Ruth reframes this as asking the law to "catch up." Choose another moment in the film where a character uses loaded or misleading language. Rewrite their argument in Ruth's style — denying the opponent's framing first, then stating your own position precisely.
Task C — Active vs. passive
Find two examples in the film where institutional or discriminatory language uses the passive voice to remove human agency from an unjust action. Rewrite each in the active voice. Then explain: why would the original speaker prefer the passive construction?

5 · Activities

Before viewing

TaskWhat to do
Legal contextFind out: What is the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause? What was Thurgood Marshall's legal strategy in Brown v. Board of Education — and why did Ginsburg study it? Note three facts.
Harvard Law School 1956Research what Harvard Law School was like for women in 1956: when were women first admitted, how many were in the class, and what careers were open to them after graduation? Note three facts.
DiscussionIs the law a good tool for achieving social change — or does law always follow society rather than lead it? Discuss in pairs, then share your view with the class.
Vocabulary previewLook at the legal vocabulary on the Vocabulary tab. Which five words do you think will appear most often in the film? Choose them and explain your reasoning.

While viewing

TaskInstructions
Presupposition logNote three moments where a character's language contains a hidden assumption. Write the line and identify the assumption.
Register contrastNote one example of Ruth's professional register and one of her domestic register. What is different — vocabulary, sentence length, tone?
The Marty questionNote three things Marty does in the film that challenge conventional gender expectations. How does the film present these — as remarkable, or as simply what equality looks like?
Strategy trackerEach time Ruth makes a deliberate strategic choice rather than an emotional one, note it. What choices does she make, and what does the film suggest she gives up each time?

After viewing

TaskInstructions
Class discussionIs Ginsburg's approach — patient, methodical, educational — the right way to fight injustice? Or are there situations where confrontation and emotion are not just acceptable but necessary?
Critical essayWrite a critical essay (250–350 words): "On the Basis of Sex presents Ruth Bader Ginsburg as a near-perfect heroine. Is this a strength or a weakness of the film?"
Essay question"The film argues that real change comes from working within institutions, not against them. Do you agree — with the film, or with that argument?" Write 250–300 words using evidence from the film and your own knowledge.

Assessment grid — critical essay

CriterionExcellentGoodNeeds work
Argument: clear position on the film's approachStrong, nuanced position maintained throughoutPosition stated but inconsistently arguedNo clear position
Evidence: uses specific scenes and linesMultiple specific examples from the filmSome examples; underdevelopedGeneral claims without evidence
Vocabulary: uses words from the unit5+ unit words used correctly3–4 unit words usedFewer than 3 unit words
Language: grammar and formal registerConsistent formal register; minimal errorsMostly clear; some errorsErrors impede meaning
Critical thinking: engages with counter-argumentsCounter-argument genuinely considered before concludingCounter-argument acknowledged brieflyOne-sided throughout
On the Basis of Sex · Film Comprehension Unit · English Language
Scroll to Top