The Eight Mountains

Film Comprehension Unit · English Language

The Eight Mountains

Felix van Groeningen & Charlotte Vandermeersch · 2022
Based on the novel Le otto montagne by Paolo Cognetti · Jury Prize, Cannes 2022
Italian dialogue / English subtitles 147 minutes Cannes Jury Prize 2022 5 sections

1 · Overview

Film overview

In the summer of 1984, Pietro — an eleven-year-old boy from Turin whose father is a passionate mountaineer — comes with his family to the village of Grana in the Italian Alps. There he meets Bruno, a local boy of the same age whose family has lived in these mountains for generations. The two boys spend the summer together, roaming the slopes and the valley. They are different in almost every way — Pietro is from the city, educated, destined to leave; Bruno is of the mountain, practical, rooted, unable to imagine being anywhere else. But between them forms one of those rare, defining friendships that neither will ever fully leave behind.

The film follows their relationship across more than three decades: separation, reunion, diverging lives, moments of deep connection, long silences, and the slow reckoning that comes when two people understand that they have chosen irreconcilably different paths. It is a film about male friendship — a subject rarely treated with this depth or patience — and about what it means to belong somewhere, and to belong to someone, without owning either.

Directors
Felix van Groeningen & Charlotte Vandermeersch
Year
2022
Stars
Luca Marinelli (Pietro), Alessandro Borghi (Bruno)
Based on
Le otto montagne, Paolo Cognetti (2016)
Language
Italian with subtitles
Rotten Tomatoes
91% — "patient, profound, breathtaking"

The title and its meaning

Buddhist / ancient Indian cosmology — the film's governing metaphor
In Buddhist and ancient Indian cosmology, the world is composed of a central mountain — Mount Meru — surrounded by eight concentric circular mountain ranges, separated by eight seas. Pietro's father poses the question in the film:
"Who learns more — the one who travels to all eight mountains, or the one who stays at the centre?"
Pietro travels — through Nepal, through relationships, through grief, through wandering. Bruno stays — in the valley, at the centre, close to what he has always known. The film refuses to say who has chosen correctly. The mountain is not a symbol; it is a question.

Two lives — a structural portrait

Pietro — the traveller
Son of a Turin chemist and a passionate mountaineer father. Educated, curious, destined for university and a world of choices. His father's love of the mountains shapes him but also burdens him — he is a man with too many horizons. He travels to Nepal, builds an environmental monitoring station, drifts through adult life without quite settling. His friendship with Bruno is the most stable thing in his life.
Bruno — the stayer
Son of a mountain stonemason, abandoned by his father. He has no school beyond the local one, no expectation of leaving, no image of a life elsewhere. He becomes a cattle farmer, a builder, a man who works with his hands in the landscape where he was born. He is not trapped — he is rooted. His attachment to the mountain is not a failure of imagination but a form of integrity.

The structure: a life told slowly

1
1984 — Childhood
First summer in Grana
Pietro and Bruno meet as eleven-year-olds. They roam the mountains together. Pietro's father takes a deep interest in Bruno — recognising in him the mountain son he could not quite make of Pietro. The summer ends; Pietro and his family return to Turin.
2
1990s — Adolescence and separation
Return visits, growing divergence
Pietro returns for summers; Bruno remains. Their friendship deepens and also stretches — they are becoming different people. Pietro's father builds a cabin in the upper pastures with Bruno's help, creating a bond between them that parallels the one with Pietro.
3
2000s — The cabin
Rebuilding the ruined house — the closest they ever are
Pietro inherits the Alpine cabin from his father and comes back to rebuild it with Bruno. They spend a winter at altitude together, building with their hands, talking without performing, living with the silence of the mountains. This is the film's emotional centre — the period in which the friendship is most fully itself.
4
2000s — Divergence
Nepal, distance, and the years between
Pietro leaves for Nepal, where he works on an environmental project in the Himalayas. Years pass. Bruno marries, has a son, continues his life in the valley. The friendship continues through letters and visits, but the distance is real.
5
Late 2000s — Loss
The end of the journey
Bruno makes an ascent that goes wrong. Pietro returns to Grana to carry out Bruno's wishes, to face the mountain that took him, and to understand — finally, too late — what Bruno's life and choices actually meant. The film's final act is an elegy and a reckoning.

Characters

Pi
Pietro
City boy, narrator, traveller · Played by Luca Marinelli (adult) / Lupo Barbiero (child)
The film's first-person narrator — we see everything through his eyes, which means we see Bruno incompletely. Pietro is the character who cannot stay, who cannot commit, who returns again and again to the mountain precisely because he keeps leaving it. Marinelli plays him as a man carrying something he cannot name — the grief of having chosen freedom and discovered that freedom is also a form of loss.
Br
Bruno
Mountain boy, Bruno who stays · Played by Alessandro Borghi (adult) / Francesco Palombelli (child)
The film's moral centre — though he never articulates a philosophy. Bruno's choices are embodied rather than reasoned: he tends cows, builds with stone, moves in the landscape with the ease of someone who has never been anywhere else. Borghi plays him with a quiet physicality — a man for whom words are a second language and action is the first. His final decision is the film's most difficult and most honest moment.
Gi
Giovanni (Pietro's father)
Chemist, mountaineer · Played by Filippo Timi
One of Italian cinema's great father figures. Giovanni loves the mountains with a fervour his family cannot always match. He adopts Bruno — emotionally if not legally — as the mountain son he always wanted. His relationship with his actual son is warmer and more complicated than either can admit. His death sets the film's final act in motion.
Fr
Francesca (Pietro's mother)
Played by Elena Lietti
A warmer, more earthly counterpoint to Giovanni's obsession. She understands her son in ways her husband cannot. Her conversations with Pietro are the film's moments of plainest emotional honesty — she says what Giovanni communicates only through action, and what Pietro is still learning to say at all.

Key themes

Two ways of living
Pietro travels; Bruno stays. The film asks which choice contains more courage — and refuses to decide. Both lives are shown with full respect.
Male friendship
Rarely portrayed with this depth in cinema. The film shows love between men that is physical (they build things together, walk together), emotional (they know each other across decades), and utterly unspoken.
Fathers and sons
Three father-son relationships run through the film. Giovanni and Pietro; Bruno's absent father; and Giovanni's surrogate adoption of Bruno. Each shapes the men the boys become.
Belonging and place
What does it mean to belong somewhere? Is it possible to be fully at home in a place — or does belonging always involve a cost?
Silence and communication
The film's most important things are communicated without words: in shared labour, in landscape, in the fact of returning. This is Italian masculine culture — and also something universal.
Loss and memory
The film is structured as retrospective — Pietro tells a story he already knows the end of. Loss is present throughout, giving the friendship a quality of elegy even in its happiest scenes.

2 · Vocabulary

Core vocabulary

TermMeaning / How it's used in the film
Alpine (adj.)Relating to the Alps, the mountain range that spans central Europe. The film is set in the Italian Alps — specifically the Aosta Valley in northwestern Italy — whose landscape is not merely a backdrop but a character: it shapes everything that happens between Pietro and Bruno.
cosmology (n.)A system of understanding the origin and structure of the universe. The film's title refers to Buddhist and ancient Indian cosmology: nine mountains, eight seas, Mount Meru at the centre. Pietro's father uses this cosmology to ask his central question about the value of travelling versus staying.
estrangement (n.)The state of being distant or alienated from someone you were once close to. Pietro and his father experience a gradual estrangement — they love each other but cannot quite reach each other — that is only partially resolved before Giovanni dies.
stonemason (n.)A craftsman who works with stone — cutting, shaping, and building. Bruno's father is a stonemason, and Bruno inherits this relationship to stone: he builds with his hands, repairs old walls, and eventually helps rebuild Pietro's cabin. The craft is a form of language between them.
transhumance (n.)The seasonal movement of livestock — typically cattle or sheep — between lowland winter pastures and high mountain summer pastures. Bruno's life as a farmer follows the rhythms of transhumance: summers in the high pastures, winters in the valley. This ancient practice structures his relationship to the mountain.
retrospective (adj./n.)Looking back at past events. The film is structured as a retrospective — Pietro narrates a story he already knows the end of, which gives every scene a quality of loss known in advance. The audience feels this even before tragedy strikes.
solitude (n.)The state of being alone, especially when chosen. Both Pietro and Bruno spend long periods alone — Pietro in Nepal, Bruno on the high pastures. The film treats solitude not as loneliness but as a form of knowing: you learn yourself most clearly when there is nothing else to look at.
pasture (n.)Land used for grazing animals, especially at higher altitudes in summer. The alpine pastures where Bruno herds his cattle are the film's highest — and most peaceful — spaces. They are where he is most fully himself.
elegy (n.)A mournful poem or other artistic work expressing grief, especially for the dead. The Eight Mountains functions as an elegy on multiple levels: for Bruno, for Giovanni, for the versions of Pietro and Bruno that existed in childhood, and for the relationship itself — which is mourned even while it is alive.
bildungsroman (n.)A German literary term for a novel that follows the psychological and moral development of a protagonist from youth to adulthood. The Eight Mountains is a bildungsroman — though an unusual one, since it follows two protagonists who develop in opposite directions.
to reconcile (v.)To restore friendly relations after a conflict; or to accept two apparently contradictory ideas as true simultaneously. Pietro must reconcile his love for Bruno with his repeated choice to leave. The film suggests this reconciliation is never complete — it is something you keep working at.
reciprocal (adj.)Given and received in equal measure; mutual. The friendship between Pietro and Bruno is reciprocal — it is not a case of one man needing the other more. The film is careful to show what each gives and what each receives.

Key lines from the film

"Who has learned more: the one who has been to all eight mountains, or the one who has been at the centre of the nine?"
Pietro's father, posing the film's central question. This is not answered — it is held. The question frames the entire film: Pietro is the one who travels to all eight mountains, Bruno the one who stays at the centre. But the film refuses to declare a winner. The question is presented not as a riddle with a solution but as a koan — a question that repays contemplation precisely because it cannot be resolved. Note the use of the present perfect ("has been") rather than the simple past: these are lives still in progress when the question is asked.
"I held this to be the highest task for a bond between two people: that each protects the solitude of the other."
Rainer Maria Rilke, quoted in the film's narration. This line — from Rilke's Letters to a Young Poet — is the closest the film comes to a philosophical statement about what the Pietro-Bruno friendship is. "Protects the solitude" is counterintuitive: we expect love to seek closeness, not to protect distance. But the film argues that the deepest relationships are those in which each person can be fully themselves — even when "fully themselves" means being somewhere else. Pietro's departures and Bruno's rootedness are both, in this frame, forms of love.
"He showed me how a mountain winter works: the long hours at the stable, the cold that settles in the bones..."
Pietro in voiceover, describing the winter at the cabin with Bruno. The film's voiceover is in the register of literature — patient, observant, precise. This is the language of the novel translated to screen: the first-person narrator who sees in detail and records with care. The phrase "settles in the bones" is physical — it puts the cold inside the body. The film consistently describes the landscape in bodily terms: you feel the mountain, you do not merely see it.
"Maybe it's enough to do one thing well in your life."
Bruno, at some point during their years together — not a grand declaration, just an observation. The understatement is typical of Bruno's register: he says important things quietly, without fanfare. "One thing" could be: the farm, the cattle, the mountain, the friendship, the craft of building. The sentence functions as a counterpoint to the film's restless Pietro, who is always looking for the next thing. "Maybe" softens it — Bruno does not lecture. He observes.

Language register in the film

Speaker/elementRegisterWhat to notice
Pietro (voiceover)Literary, retrospective, preciseThe film's narration is derived from the novel's first-person voice. It is more formal and observant than Pietro's spoken dialogue — the voice of someone writing about a life he has already lived. The gap between how Pietro speaks and how he narrates is itself a form of character revelation: what we can say about our lives looking back is always clearer than what we can say while living them.
Bruno (dialogue)Spare, physical, understatementBruno speaks very little. When he does, his sentences are short and declarative. He does not explain himself or philosophise. He says what is true — plainly, without decoration. This is mountain Italian: a culture in which speech is economical and action is primary. His most important communications are non-verbal.
Giovanni (dialogue)Passionate, slightly grandiose, lovingPietro's father speaks with the conviction of a man who has found meaning in the mountains and wants to share it. His register is warmer than his emotional availability — he talks about love and beauty more easily than he expresses them to the people around him. Note how he speaks about the mountains versus how he speaks to Pietro.
The landscapeSilent — but communicatingThe mountains say nothing. But the film argues that they communicate everything that the characters cannot. Ruben Impens's cinematography — shot in the square Academy ratio (4:3) rather than widescreen — frames the mountains with unusual intimacy. The landscape is not vastness; it is presence. Study the shots that linger on rock, sky, and silence: what are they saying?
Silences between Pietro and BrunoThe film's primary languageThe most important exchanges in the film occur in silence: the hours at the cabin building together, the walks, the meals eaten without conversation. This is the film's argument about male friendship — that it communicates through shared activity rather than spoken intimacy. To read the film well, you must read what the silences contain.

Vocabulary task

Without using a dictionary, guess the meaning of these words from their context in the film.

WordMy guess (from context)Confirmed meaning
estrangement
transhumance
solitude
elegy
reciprocal

3 · Questions

Literal comprehension

Answer using facts directly stated in the film.

1
How do Pietro and Bruno first meet — and what is each boy's family background?
2
What does Pietro inherit from his father — and what project does this lead him and Bruno to undertake together?
3
What does Pietro do after leaving Grana as an adult — and where does he go in Asia?
4
What happens to Bruno at the end of the film — and what task does he leave for Pietro?
Interpretive comprehension

Think about why characters act as they do.

5
Pietro's father Giovanni seems more emotionally connected to Bruno than to Pietro. Why — and what does this say about what Giovanni wanted from his own son?
6
The film is narrated from Pietro's point of view. Bruno is never seen from the inside — we only know him through what Pietro observes. How does this limited perspective shape our understanding of Bruno — and what might Bruno say if he were the narrator?
7
The Rilke quotation — "that each protects the solitude of the other" — is used as a definition of what their friendship is. Is this an adequate description of what you see in the film? What does it capture, and what does it leave out?
Critical comprehension

Evaluate and argue. Support your view with evidence.

8
The film's central question — "who has learned more, the traveller or the one who stays?" — is never answered. Is this the right artistic choice? Does the film have a hidden preference for one life over the other — and if so, which?
9
The film has been criticised for its treatment of women — Pietro's mother and Bruno's girlfriend are "peripheral at best." Is this a fair criticism? Can a film about male friendship justify marginalising its female characters?
10
Bruno's final decision — the climb that kills him — can be read as a form of freedom, a form of failure, or a form of love. Which reading does the film support — and which do you find most convincing?
Creative response

Choose one. Write 150–250 words.

Option A
Write a letter from Bruno to Pietro — set during the winter they spent together at the cabin, before either of them knew how the story would end. Bruno does not write letters easily; this one takes him a long time. What does he want to say — and what does he find he cannot?
Option B
Write the version of the film told from Bruno's perspective — a brief interior monologue during one specific scene of your choice. What is Bruno thinking that he never says? What does he understand about himself and about Pietro that Pietro cannot see from the outside?

4 · Language

The Eight Mountains is a film of great verbal restraint. Much of its most important communication happens without words — in shared physical labour, in the landscape, in the silences between two men who have known each other for thirty years. Studying the film's language means studying what words are chosen when words are chosen, and understanding what is being communicated when they are not.

Scene-by-scene language analysis

The central question Giovanni's koan — a question that structures a film
Giovanni (Pietro's father)
"Consider the ancient map of the world: nine mountains and eight seas. Who has learned more — the one who has visited all eight mountains, or the one who has stayed at the centre?"
The koan structure
A koan is a question from Zen Buddhist tradition that cannot be answered through logical reasoning — it must be held and contemplated. Giovanni's question has this quality: no amount of analysis resolves it. Both Pietro (the traveller) and Bruno (the stayer) are equally plausible answers. The film lasts two and a half hours and does not resolve the question — which is itself an argument that the question is the point.
Present perfect: lives in progress
"Who has been to all eight mountains / who has been at the centre" — the present perfect tense indicates completed action with present relevance. At the moment Giovanni asks this, neither Pietro nor Bruno has yet lived the life that will be the answer. The tense implies that the answer is knowable — but only retrospectively. Pietro will only be able to answer this question after Bruno is gone.
Function in the narrative
This question is asked early — and then the film is the answer. Everything that follows is an exploration of what it means to travel and what it means to stay. The question does not frame the film from the outside; it lives inside it, returning implicitly every time Pietro leaves and Bruno remains. This is what literary critics call a "central image" — a single idea that organises everything around it.
The cabin winter Shared labour as language — what is communicated without speech
Scene description
Pietro and Bruno at work on the ruined cabin: carrying stone, mixing mortar, lifting walls. Hours pass. They eat together in silence. They work in rhythm without needing to coordinate. The film lingers on hands, on stone, on the small achievements of each day.
Labour as intimacy
The film argues that men communicate love through shared work. Pietro and Bruno do not discuss their feelings for each other; they build a house. The house is the conversation. Every stone placed is a form of trust, of commitment, of presence. The language of labour — rhythm, coordination, the small sounds of work — is the film's most eloquent language.
The Academy ratio
The film is shot in the 4:3 Academy ratio — almost square, like an old photograph. This is a formal choice that changes how the mountains feel. Rather than making them vast and wide (the typical landscape shot), the ratio makes them tall and close — pressing in on the figures. The landscape becomes intimate rather than sublime. This is visual language making an argument about how these men relate to the mountain.
For discussion
Think of activities in your own life where communication happens without words — sport, cooking, walking with someone, working alongside someone. What can be communicated in those situations that cannot easily be said? Does the film persuade you that these forms of communication can be as deep as spoken language?
Bruno's understatement "Maybe it's enough to do one thing well" — the ethics of plainness
Bruno
"Maybe it's enough to do one thing well in your life."
Understatement as philosophy
Bruno's remark is delivered as an observation, not a manifesto. The hedging "maybe" softens it; the simplicity of "one thing well" is almost modest. But the sentence contains an entire philosophy of life — one that contradicts the assumption that a good life requires variety, achievement, accumulation. Bruno is not arguing against Pietro's life; he is describing his own. The understatement is itself a form of integrity.
Contrast with Pietro's register
Pietro's narration is literary, searching, and full of secondary questions. Bruno's speech is declarative and plain. The contrast is not that Bruno is less intelligent than Pietro — it is that he uses language differently. He says what is true without analysis. Pietro analyses what is true without always finding it. This is a language portrait of two different relationships to knowledge and to life.
The one thing Bruno does well
What is the one thing Bruno does well? The film offers several candidates: farming, building, being present to the mountain, friendship with Pietro. The line does not specify — which is appropriate, since Bruno would not catalogue his own virtues. But Pietro, narrating, knows the answer. And so, by the end of the film, does the audience.

Grammar in context

StructureHow it appearsWhy it matters
Present perfect for retrospective meaning
"Who has been to all eight mountains?"
Giovanni's question uses the present perfect — "has been" — implying completed experience with ongoing relevance. At the moment of asking, neither man has yet made his choices. The tense implies the answer will come.The present perfect in English connects the past to the present: it describes completed actions that still matter now. In the film's question, it positions life choices as experiences that will one day be evaluable — but are not yet complete.
Understatement and hedging
"Maybe it's enough..."
Bruno's characteristic register is hedged and understated. "Maybe" — not "it is." "Enough" — not "the best." This is not uncertainty; it is modesty about making grand claims.Understatement is saying less than the situation warrants. In Bruno's case, it is a form of respect — for the listener, for the complexity of life, for the possibility that he might be wrong. Recognising understatement is essential for reading Italian and European registers where grandeur is suspect.
First-person narration as limitation
"I think Bruno felt..." / "I couldn't know what he..."
Pietro's narration occasionally acknowledges that it cannot fully access Bruno's interior. These moments of admitted limitation make the narration more honest and more poignant.First-person narrators are always limited — they can only know what they experienced. When a narrator acknowledges this limitation, it raises the credibility of everything else they say. Pietro's admission that he cannot fully know Bruno is also the film's most honest statement about friendship.
The body as language
[Scene descriptions: hands on stone, shared silences, parallel movement]
The film's most important language is non-verbal: body posture, touch, proximity, the rhythm of shared work. Cinema studies this calls "kinesics" — the study of communication through body movement.Much of human communication is non-verbal — research suggests over 50% in face-to-face contexts. The film makes visible what usually goes unnoticed: that friendship between men is often expressed through what they do together, not what they say.

Language and film features

①
The Academy ratio — framing as argument
The film was shot in the 4:3 Academy ratio, which was standard before widescreen became the norm. This choice is deliberate: the square ratio makes the mountains tall rather than wide, intimate rather than panoramic. It also places human figures in a different relationship to the landscape — they are not dwarfed by it, but contained within it. The format is itself a statement about how Pietro and Bruno relate to the Alps: not as spectators of vastness, but as inhabitants of a specific, known place.
②
The novel's voice — literature on screen
Paolo Cognetti's novel is narrated in the first person by Pietro, in a register that is precise, observant, and literary. The filmmakers chose to preserve this through voiceover narration — Pietro's interior voice continues in the film even where dialogue would be easier. This is a choice about fidelity to the source: the novel's language is part of what makes it beautiful, and the film refuses to abandon it. The result is a film that feels like reading and watching simultaneously — which is appropriate for a story about a man who communicates better in writing than in speech.
③
Italian as the film's language — why subtitles matter
The film is in Italian — a language that English-speaking students encounter through reading rather than listening. This creates an unusual relationship with the film's dialogue: you are reading and watching simultaneously, which slows down your processing of both. This is not a disadvantage — it is an invitation to pay closer attention to image and sound, since the words come to you more slowly. Notice how much the film communicates that does not require translation: the landscape, the physical performances, the music of Daniel Norgren, the silences.
④
Time and patience — the film's formal commitment
The Eight Mountains is 147 minutes long and moves slowly. This is not a failure of editing — it is the argument. A friendship that spans thirty years cannot be conveyed in ninety minutes. The film's length is its claim about how friendship actually works: not in dramatic revelations but in accumulated time, shared meals, winters together, years apart. The patience the film asks of its audience is the same patience that the friendship asks of Pietro and Bruno. If you find it slow, ask yourself what that says about your own relationship to time and attention.

Language tasks

Task A — The central question
Giovanni's question — "who has learned more?" — is the film's central koan. Write two versions of an answer: one arguing that Pietro (the traveller) has learned more, one arguing that Bruno (the stayer) has. For each version: use at least two specific moments from the film as evidence. Then write one sentence saying which answer the film seems to favour — and whether you agree.
Task B — Reading non-verbal communication
Choose two scenes in the film where important communication happens without dialogue. For each: describe what is happening physically (what the characters are doing, how they are positioned, what they are not saying), and explain what is being communicated. What would be lost if the directors had added dialogue to make the communication explicit?
Task C — Pietro vs. Bruno's register
Compare Pietro's narration register with Bruno's dialogue register. Find one example of each. Describe the specific language features: sentence length, vocabulary choice, use of hedging or certainty, presence or absence of emotion. What does each register reveal about how that person relates to the world — and to the other?

5 · Activities

Before viewing

TaskWhat to do
The Italian AlpsFind out: where are the Italian Alps, and what is the Aosta Valley? What is the landscape like — altitude, climate, vegetation? Look at some photographs before watching. Note three things you observe.
The Rilke quotationLook up the full context of "that each protects the solitude of the other" from Rilke's Letters to a Young Poet. What is Rilke saying about love and solitude? Do you agree with it? Note your initial response before watching.
The novelIf possible, read the opening pages of Paolo Cognetti's novel Le otto montagne (The Eight Mountains). Compare the written register with the film's. What changes in translation from page to screen?
DiscussionThink of the longest friendship in your life. What has kept it going? What has been the hardest moment in it? You do not need to share the details — just hold them in mind as you watch.

While viewing

TaskInstructions
Silence logNote five moments where something important is communicated without words. For each: what is happening, and what is being communicated?
The parallel livesNote two moments that show what Pietro's life has become as an adult, and two that show Bruno's. How has each man changed from the child we met? What has stayed the same?
The father triangleNote moments that show: (a) Giovanni's relationship with Pietro; (b) Giovanni's relationship with Bruno; (c) Bruno's absent father. What does each relationship cost, and what does it give?
The mountainNote how the camera frames the mountain at different points in the film. Does it always look the same? How does the cinematography change your sense of the mountain's meaning at different moments?

After viewing

TaskInstructions
Class discussionWho has learned more — Pietro or Bruno? Go around the room: each person gives their verdict and their most important piece of evidence. Does the class reach consensus?
Film reviewWrite a film review (150–200 words) that engages with both the film's emotional power and its formal choices (length, silence, Academy ratio, Italian language). Who would you recommend it to — and who would you honestly warn away?
Personal essayWrite a short personal reflection (150–200 words): what does the film suggest about what friendships need in order to survive over decades? Do you agree — and does your own experience of friendship confirm or challenge what the film shows?
Essay question"The Eight Mountains argues that the deepest communication between people happens in silence. Does the film prove this — or does it rely on its own verbal beauty to make the case?" Write 250–300 words.

Assessment grid — film review

CriterionExcellentGoodNeeds work
Engages with emotional power and formal choicesBoth addressed with specific evidenceOne aspect dominant; other briefly mentionedOnly one aspect discussed
Addresses the film's central question (traveller vs. stayer)Question engaged with and a position takenQuestion mentioned but not arguedQuestion not addressed
Vocabulary: uses words from the unit5+ unit words used correctly3–4 unit words usedFewer than 3 unit words
Language: grammar and registerConsistent formal register; minimal errorsMostly clear; some errorsErrors impede meaning
Length: 150–200 words150–200 words130–149 or 201–220Under 130 or over 220
The Eight Mountains · Film Comprehension Unit · English Language
Scroll to Top