Contra
Screenplay by Doron Wisotzky · Based on the French film Le Brio (Yvan Attal, 2017) · German Film Prize nomination, Best Film 2022
1 · Overview
Film overview
Frankfurt am Main, present day. Naima Hamid is late for her first lecture as a law student at university. It is not easy to be on time: her mother works long hours for low pay; her brother cannot be counted on to look after the baby. She slips into the lecture hall just as Professor Richard Pohl is warming up. The door bangs shut. Pohl erupts — a tirade that mentions suicide vests, names her "Fatima," and ends with a remark that leaves no ambiguity about what he thinks of people who look like her. Another student films it. By the time the lecture ends, the video is going viral.
Pohl is a star of the Frankfurt law faculty — arrogant, brilliant, and well-connected. He has insulted students before. But this time the university president, under public pressure, gives him an ultimatum: mentor Naima through the rounds of a national student debate competition, and the disciplinary hearing may go better for him. Naima, furious at being instrumentalised, has no interest in being anyone's redemption project. She is assigned to participate anyway.
What follows is a comedy about rhetoric, racism, and the distance between having a good argument and being able to deliver it — and about what happens when two people who have every reason to dislike each other are forced to work together long enough to see each other clearly. Contra is sharp, funny, and politically alert. It is also, ultimately, a film about voice: who gets one, who earns one, and what it takes to be heard in a country where some people's right to speak is still contested.
The title — and what "contra" means
Two worlds — forced together
The structure: argument by argument
Characters
Key themes
2 · Vocabulary
Core vocabulary
| Term | Meaning / How it's used in the film |
|---|---|
| rhetoric (n.) | The art of using language effectively and persuasively, especially in speaking or writing. The film is set in and around the world of competitive debate, where rhetoric is the central skill. Pohl teaches Naima that rhetoric is not about expressing your genuine beliefs — it is about constructing the most effective possible argument for a given position. This distinction between persuasion and truth is one of the film's governing tensions. |
| xenophobia (n.) | Dislike or fear of people from other countries or cultures. Pohl's opening tirade is a case study in xenophobia — casual, performed, wrapped in the register of wit. The film distinguishes xenophobia from the more systemic racism of the institution, suggesting that the latter is more consequential even if it is less obviously ugly. |
| to go viral (v. phrase) | To spread rapidly and widely across the internet, typically via social media. Pohl's lecture-hall remarks are filmed and go viral within hours — triggering a public petition and a disciplinary process. The film uses the viral moment to examine what kind of accountability the internet actually creates: immediate, public, but also easily managed by institutions that control the subsequent narrative. |
| disciplinary hearing (n.) | A formal institutional process to investigate whether a person has violated professional rules, and to determine consequences. Pohl's disciplinary hearing is the threat that drives the plot: he must mentor Naima in order to demonstrate sufficient remorse before the committee. The film is interested in what this kind of institutional accountability actually achieves — whether it changes the person or simply manages the institution's reputation. |
| integration (n.) | The process by which people of different backgrounds are incorporated into a society on equal terms. German political discourse in the 2000s and 2010s was saturated with debates about "Integration" — whether immigrants and their children had successfully adopted German values and practices. The film is sceptical of this framing: Naima is entirely German in many ways, but is still required to "integrate." The word implies a one-directional process (the newcomer adapts to the society) which the film contests. |
| tokenism (n.) | The practice of making a small symbolic effort to include members of minority groups, in order to create an appearance of equality without actually achieving it. When Naima realises the university is using her debate participation to manage its public image rather than to support her, she is confronting tokenism — the liberal institution's version of the problem that Pohl's overt racism represents more crudely. |
| pro and contra (phrase) | Arguments for and against a position, from the Latin. In formal debate, one side argues "pro" (for) and one side argues "contra" (against) a given motion. The film's title refers to this structure — and to the fact that both Naima and Pohl are initially "contra" each other. But it also gestures at a broader idea: that the capacity to argue both sides of a question is not moral relativism but intellectual training. The film respects this training while being aware of its limits. |
| systemic racism (n.) | Racism that is embedded in the structures, policies, and practices of institutions, rather than expressed purely in individual behaviour. Pohl's tirade is individual racism. The university's management of Naima's story — using her as a symbol rather than supporting her as a person — is an example of systemic racism: better-intentioned, harder to name, and in some ways more resistant to change. |
| Kartoffeln (n. German) | Literally "potatoes" — a term used in German youth slang (originating in migrant communities) to refer to white Germans, often with a slightly mocking or affectionate edge. In the film, Mo's "Kartoffeln-Party" — a celebration of his newly won German citizenship — uses the word with self-aware irony: he has become officially German; the party celebrates this achievement with the language that marks the cultural divide. |
| refutation (n.) | The action of proving a statement or theory wrong. A key skill in competitive debate is refutation: dismantling your opponent's argument by exposing its logical flaws or factual errors. The film's most powerful scene is Naima's refutation of the argument that Islam is a religion of terror — using the rhetorical tools Pohl has taught her, but drawing on knowledge and experience he could not access. |
| cancel culture (n.) | A phenomenon in which people are publicly ostracised or professionally marginalised for behaviour or statements considered unacceptable, often via social media campaigns. The film engages with cancel culture in its opening: the online petition to dismiss Pohl is an instance of it. The film's position is nuanced — it does not defend Pohl, but it asks what institutional accountability actually means when it is driven by reputational management rather than by justice. |
| articulate (adj./v.) | As adjective: able to express ideas clearly and effectively. As verb: to express or explain something clearly. Naima's journey in the film is partly a journey toward becoming articulate — not in the sense of learning to speak (she is highly intelligent from the start) but in the sense of finding the formal registers and rhetorical techniques that allow her anger and intelligence to be heard in spaces that would otherwise dismiss her. |
Key lines from the film
Language register in the film
| Speaker / element | Register | What to notice |
|---|---|---|
| Pohl (lecturing) | Formal academic German, sharp, aphoristic | Pohl's lecture register is precise and performative — the language of a man who knows that how something is said can carry as much weight as what is said. His wit is a form of dominance: he controls the room through register. His insults are framed as asides, as wit, as academic impatience — which is partly how he has protected himself from consequences for so long. The register of "cleverness" can be a cover for cruelty. |
| Pohl (with Naima) | Initially contemptuous; gradually more engaged | As the mentoring proceeds, Pohl's register toward Naima shifts. The contempt remains in form — he does not suddenly become warm — but it loses its certainty. He begins to respond to her as an intellect rather than as a category. This shift is expressed through register: he starts asking her genuine questions rather than delivering verdicts. His language becomes slightly less finished, slightly less performed. |
| Naima (early) | Colloquial, emotional, Frankfurt German | At the start of the film, Naima's spoken register is the everyday German of a young woman from a working-class Frankfurt family — direct, emotionally present, switching occasionally into Arabic with her mother and brother. It is not "incorrect" German; it is a specific register that carries class and community markers. One of the film's central movements is Naima learning the formal debate register without abandoning the register she arrived with. |
| Naima (debating) | Formal, controlled, rhetorically precise | By the final debate, Naima speaks in a register Pohl has partly taught her — formal, structured, evidence-based — but with a dimension he could not teach her: personal authority. She is not performing the register of academic German; she is using it as a tool while remaining herself. The film's argument is that this combination — formal skill plus authentic presence — is what genuine eloquence looks like. |
| Mo | Warm, direct, spoken from the heart | Mo's German is unhurried and straightforward — the language of someone who means what he says without rhetorical performance. He is the film's counterweight to the debate world: a reminder that language does not need to be formal or brilliant to communicate truth. When Naima uses a rhetorical technique to coax Mo into admitting he loves her, the scene is both funny and revealing: rhetoric can be used even in the most personal moments. |
Vocabulary task
Without using a dictionary, guess the meaning of these words from their context in the film.
| Word | My guess (from context) | Confirmed meaning |
|---|---|---|
| xenophobia | ||
| tokenism | ||
| rhetoric | ||
| refutation | ||
| articulate |
3 · Questions
Answer using facts directly stated in the film.
Think about why characters act as they do.
Evaluate and argue. Support your view with evidence.
Choose one. Write 150–250 words.
4 · Language
Contra is a film about language — about who gets to use it, in what register, in what rooms, with what effect. Its subject is debate, which means that every conversation in the film is also a lesson in rhetoric: how arguments are constructed, how they are delivered, and how the gap between a brilliant argument and an honest one can be both a technical problem and a moral one. Studying this film's language means studying the relationship between form and power — between how something is said and who it is said by, and whether those two things can ever be fully separated.
Scene-by-scene language analysis
Grammar in context
| Structure | How it appears | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| The assignment structure in debate "You argue what you're given, not what you believe." | Competitive debate assigns positions randomly — speakers argue "pro" or "contra" regardless of personal conviction. This formal structure detaches the speaker from the content of the argument, making rhetoric a technical skill rather than an expression of belief. | The debate structure raises a question about the relationship between language and conviction: can you argue something you do not believe without being dishonest? The film suggests this is possible in formal debate — but dangerous in life. Pohl's problem is that he has made his public language so performative that he has lost track of the difference. |
| Generalisation and its fallacy "Some X are Y, therefore all X are Y." | The central logical error Naima's refutation targets: the move from a particular instance to a universal claim. The film uses this formal structure to expose the logic underlying Pohl's xenophobia — which operates by the same fallacy at every point. | Identifying logical fallacies is a transferable analytical skill. The fallacy of generalisation underlies most forms of prejudice — racial, national, religious. The film uses the formal debate context to name the structure explicitly, which means students can apply it to arguments they encounter outside the cinema. |
| Code-switching [Naima: German with family; German with Pohl; debate register] | Naima moves between registers throughout the film: colloquial Frankfurt German with Mo and her family; a more formal register with Pohl; and the precise, structured language of debate competition. This code-switching is not performed or calculated — it is the natural behaviour of a person who inhabits multiple worlds. | Code-switching — the practice of moving between languages or registers depending on context — is universal but is often marked as inauthentic when done by people from migrant backgrounds. The film presents Naima's code-switching as a skill and a form of intelligence, not as a failure of "integration." Her multiple registers do not mean she has no authentic self; they mean she has several contexts. |
| Mis-naming as power "Fatima" / "Naima" — the wrong name and the right one | Pohl's substitution of "Fatima" for Naima's actual name is a specific grammatical act of erasure. The film tracks the use of her actual name as a marker of whether she is being seen. By the end of the film, the person who consistently gets her name right — and uses it — is Mo. | Names are the most personal unit of language. To consistently mis-name someone — especially by substituting a stereotypically ethnic name — is to refuse to engage with them as an individual. The film uses this specific grammatical act to make a broader argument: language that refuses to see the particular (this person, this name) in favour of the general (her type, her category) is not neutral. It is a form of harm. |
Language and film features
Language tasks
5 · Activities
Before viewing
| Task | What to do |
|---|---|
| Migration in Germany | Find out: what is the history of migration to Germany since 1945? Who are the main migrant communities, and how did they come to be in Germany? What does the term "Gastarbeiter" (guest worker) mean, and why is it politically contentious? Note three things that help you understand the world of the film. |
| Competitive debate | Find out: how does formal competitive debate work? What are the rules about assigned positions? What skills are being judged? If possible, watch two minutes of a competitive debate on YouTube — in any language — and note what you observe about register, structure, and delivery. |
| Le Brio (2017) | The film is a remake of the French film Le Brio. Find out: what is the French context for the original film? How is the situation of migrant communities in France similar to and different from Germany? What might be gained or lost in moving the story from Paris to Frankfurt? |
| Discussion | Think of a moment when you were in a formal speaking situation — a presentation, a debate, an interview. Did your register change from how you normally speak? What made it difficult, and what made it possible? Hold this experience in mind as you watch the film. |
While viewing
| Task | Instructions |
|---|---|
| Register log | Note three moments when a character's register shifts — when they speak differently than they did before, or differently from their usual way of speaking. For each: who is speaking, what changes, and what triggers the change? |
| Arguments pro and contra | Note three moments in the film where a character makes an argument — formal or informal. For each: what is the argument, is it a good one, and does the other character actually engage with it or deflect it? |
| Tokenism and recognition | Note moments when the university or other characters support Naima. For each: is this support genuine recognition of her as a person, or is it instrumental — using her for the institution's purposes? Is it possible to tell the difference at the time, or only in retrospect? |
| Mo as counterpoint | Note every scene involving Mo. What does he say and do — and how does his presence comment on the world of the university and the debate competition without ever entering it? What does the film say about the relationship between formal eloquence and genuine wisdom? |
After viewing
| Task | Instructions |
|---|---|
| Class debate | Hold a class debate on one of the film's own motions: "This house believes that formal rhetoric training is the most effective tool against prejudice." Assign positions — some students must argue pro, some contra, regardless of personal belief. Afterwards: how did it feel to argue a position you did not hold? What did this teach you about the relationship between argument and conviction? |
| Film review | Write a film review (150–200 words) for a student audience. Your review should: briefly describe the film's subject; assess the central performances; engage with the question of whether the film handles its political themes with sufficient depth or falls into comfortable resolution; and give a final recommendation. |
| Personal reflection | Write a short personal reflection (150–200 words): the film argues that learning formal rhetoric is a form of empowerment for people who are usually not heard in formal spaces. Do you agree? Are there limits to this argument? Can learning the language of power also be a form of assimilation that costs something? |
| Essay question | "Contra suggests that racism in institutions is more damaging than overt individual prejudice because it is harder to name and harder to fight." To what extent does the film support this argument? Write 250–300 words, using specific evidence from the film. |
Assessment grid — film review
| Criterion | Excellent | Good | Needs work |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engages with the film's political themes | Both individual racism and institutional tokenism addressed with specific evidence | Racism mentioned; institutional dimension not addressed | Plot summary only; political dimension absent |
| Discusses performance (Farooq or Herbst) | Specific moment cited; what the actor does described precisely | Actor praised but without specific evidence | Performances not mentioned |
| Assesses the film's handling of its resolution | Considers whether ending is earned; identifies what is left unresolved | Ending mentioned; not evaluated critically | Ending not addressed |
| Vocabulary: uses words from the unit | 5+ unit words used correctly and naturally | 3–4 unit words used | Fewer than 3 unit words |
| Length: 150–200 words | 150–200 words | 130–149 or 201–220 | Under 130 or over 220 |